Scorecard for Rising Star

Concept/Originality - 8/10

The blending of 1980s NYC crime drama with a psychologically layered murder mystery gives the project a strong and distinctive hook. The dynamic between two reluctant allies from different worlds adds freshness to a familiar genre.

Structure/Pacing - 7/10

The script follows a three-act structure with clear escalation, but early momentum could tighten slightly to engage faster. Flashbacks and parallel scenes between Logan and Malik are effective but occasionally interrupt flow.

​

Character Development - 8/10

Both Logan and Malik are fully realized with clear motivations and internal conflicts. The contrast in their worldviews and methods brings tension and growth. Secondary characters are solid but could benefit from added nuance.

​

Dialogue - 8/10

Period-accurate, often sharp, and character-specific. Malik’s voice in particular stands out with authenticity. Occasional lines feel expositional or on-the-nose, but overall, the dialogue supports tone and pace well.

Theme/Meaning - 7/10

The script explores justice, trauma, masculinity, and systemic neglect. These themes resonate but could be drawn out more explicitly in the climax for maximum emotional punch.

Cohesion/Execution - 8/10

Technically sound with strong narrative control and a consistent tone. The 1980s atmosphere is well-rendered without feeling overindulgent. Some plot elements could be slightly streamlined.

Visual Potential - 9/10

Neon-lit streets, grainy precincts, underground clubs, and a killer’s coded calling card — this story offers bold, cinematic imagery that evokes classic ‘80s thrillers while feeling fresh.

​

Marketability - 8/10

A strong crime/mystery hybrid with true-crime flavor and prestige appeal. Appeals to fans of Zodiac, Seven, Mindhunter, and The Deuce. Could be adapted for streaming or limited series with minimal changes.

Emotional Impact - 7/10

The tension is strong, particularly around Malik’s arc. Logan’s internal reckoning could be more emotionally exposed in the final act to raise stakes. The killer's motive is compelling but could land harder.

Overall Impression - 8/10

Rising Star is a polished, atmospheric noir-thriller with commercial and festival appeal. Its emotionally wounded protagonists, evocative setting, and layered mystery elevate it above genre convention. With modest revisions, this script could absolutely reach finalist rounds.

​

Final Score: 78 / 100

SUMMARY

Rising Star has the elements Competitions often reward: a strong concept, layered protagonists, and meaningful subtext within a genre frame.